Posts in Pauline Studies
Paul on the “Elementary Principles of the World” in Galatians 4:3 -- Occult Powers or Legalism?

In verse 3 of Galatians 4, Paul applies the legal analogy of heir and an estate mentioned in Galatians 4:1-2 to the situation at hand—Jewish legalism in Galatia. No doubt, Israel’s history is in Paul’s mind when making this analogy. He’s thinking of Israel’s liberation from their bondage in Egypt under cruel task masters.[1] “In the same way we also, when we were children, [we] were enslaved to the elementary principles of the world.” The Greek term translated “elementary principles” is stoicheia (στοιχεια), which refers to the “rudimentary principles of morality and religion, more specifically the requirements of legalism by which people lived before Christ.”[2] When we were children [in Paul’s illustration], we were enslaved to the basic “principles of the world.”

A number of commentators contend the term refers to “angelic powers” or cosmic forces–spiritual and occult forces.[3] But as one writer points out, the connection of the stoicheia with immaturity, as well as the fact that the law is an instrument of bondage, supports the argument that the reference is more likely referring to, “elementary imperfect teaching . . . . To accept the Jewish law or some equivalent system is to come under slavery to some imperfect doctrine. But if stoicheia denotes elemental spirits, then it has to be explained how submitting to the regulations of the Jewish law is tantamount to being enslaved by these spirits.”[4]

To read the rest, follow the link below

Read More
Some Thoughts on Paul's Mention of the Corinthian Practice of Baptism on Behalf of the Dead (1 Corinthians 15:29)

1 Corinthians 15:29 — “Otherwise, what do people mean by being baptized on behalf of the dead?”

Verse 29 of 1 Corinthians 15 is one of the most peculiar verses in the New Testament. Paul’s statement about this Corinthian practice raises a major interpretive problem which has plagued the church from the beginning–“what is this business of baptizing people on behalf of those who have already died?” There is no comparable statement anywhere in the Old or New Testaments. Conzelmann calls verse 29 the most hotly disputed text in the entire epistle.[1] He may be right. One prominent New Testament scholar counted thirty different interpretations, while another counted forty.[2] Still another commentator, who must have had better research assistants than the others, identified over 200 interpretations of this unexpected passage.[3] Yet, putting all the variety of interpretations aside, Paul’s reason for mentioning this practice is crystal clear. If there is no bodily resurrection of the dead at the end of the age, why then are people being baptized for the dead? The Corinthian practice (whatever it is) makes no sense whatsoever, if there is no resurrection.

Most of the proposed answers to this practice assert that this is some sort of vicarious baptism on behalf of the dead–recently departed or otherwise. One widely held view is that according to the second clause of the verse, (“baptized for them”–hupere) people were being vicariously baptized in the place of those who had already died, presumably without having been baptized before death. This particular baptism was being done so that the benefits of baptism would apply to people who had already died without themselves being baptized so as to protect them from the demonic, or claim for them a place in the afterlife.[4] This would reflect the Corinthian’s struggle to properly understand spiritual things, especially what happens at death.

To read the rest, follow the link below

Read More
A New "Pauline Studies" Resource List

Over the life of the Riddleblog and the Blessed Hope Podcast, I have reviewed and introduced a number of books on various aspects of Pauline studies. I’ve also written a number of long-form and short essays on various Pauline texts and topics. I thought it might be useful to assemble them all in one place to make it easier to access them, especially for those who consult the “show notes” for the various episodes of the Blessed Hope Podcast.

The resources will be divided into 1). Book Reviews and Notices, 2). Essays at the Riddleblog, and 3). Links to Important Pauline Resources. Although I’ve completed Paul’s Letters to the Galatians, 1 & 2 Thessalonians, and I’m wrapping up 1 Corinthian, Lord willing, I’ll soon be going through 2 Corinthians and then Romans, so I thought a single page with all of the resources would be useful.

This page will be regularly updated. You can find it here: Pauline Studies and Resources (listed under the Book Reviews and Recommended Reading tab above)

Read More