The Third Attribute in the Nicene Creed – Catholicity
It is useful to begin with a brief survey of historical reflection on catholicity of the church:
Avery Dulles (a Roman Catholic theologian): “Cyril of Jerusalem in his Catechetical Lectures gives the fullest discussion of the term in Christian antiquity. He assigns five reasons why the Church is called catholic: it extends to the ends of the earth; it teaches all the doctrine needed for salvation; it brings every sort of human being under obedience; it cures every kind of sin; and it possesses every form of virtue.” (Dulles, The Catholicity of the Church, 14)
Dulles continues: “The Orthodox churches have continued to claim catholicity, which for them means, above all else, adherence to the fullness of the faith as handed down from the Fathers.” Dulles, The Catholicity of the Church, 15)
Edmund Clowney (Presbyterian): “The Greek term katholikos means that which is universal or general, having to do with the whole; it is not used in the New Testament to describe the church. The early church fathers used it to express an important New Testament teaching: that the church as a whole is more than the local church.” (Clowney, The Church, 91)
Clowney: “As the church struggled against false teaching, the term ‘catholic’ came to be used to describe the orthodox church as distinct from the Gnostic, Montanist and Arian heresies . . . . Catholicity took yet another meaning when the Novatians [who did not admit the lapsed] and later the Donatists held to orthodox theology, but separated from the church . . . . Augustine appealed to the geographical spread of the catholic church. . .” Reformers replied to Roman Catholics “by pointing to another dimension of catholicity: its extension in time.” (The Church, 91-92)
Reformed Teaching
Louis Berkhof addresses catholicity:
Protestants again “apply this attribute primarily to the invisible Church, which can be called catholic in a far truer sense than any one of the existing organizations . . . . The invisible Church is primarily the real catholic Church, because she includes all believers on earth at any particular time, no one excepted; because, consequently, she also has her members among all the nations of the world that were evangelized; and because she exercises a controlling influence on the entire life of man in all its phases. Secondarily, they also ascribe the attribute of catholicity to the visible Church.” Berkhof (Systematic Theology, 575)
To read the rest of this essay, follow the link below
Read More